Stata Coding Practices: Visualization

Modern Stata versions have extremely powerful graphics capabilities which allow the rapid creation of publication-quality graphics from almost any kind of tabular data. Although the default graphical commands and settings leave much to be desired, the customizability and interoperability of Stata's visualization tools mean that almost any imaginable output can be rendered using Stata's built-in graphics engine.

Read First

Stata graphics are typically created using one of four command types. Each has specific use cases, strengths, and weaknesses, and it is important to be familiar with the abilities and limitations of each when considering which to use to create a particular visualization. All four methods (except some user-written commands) use the same basic styling syntax discussed in this article.

• The graph command suite creates pre-packaged visualizations, typically based on Stata's native collapse syntax and statistics.
• The twoway suite, which is the most commonly used tool, allows a flexible and open-ended approach to visualizing any amount of information in an abstract set of axes.
• Built-in graphical commands (such as lowess) offer pre-packaged visualizations that do not follow the graph style. These commands are typically better used within a twoway environment and may behave differently when used independently.
• User-written commands (such as iegraph or spmap) create custom visualizations, but typically have unique purpose-built syntaxes and cannot be integrated in a twoway environment.

General Graphics Tools

Graphics options

There are an enormous number of options available for each specific type of graph in Stata, and we will not cover those here. When drawing a graph, refer to the specific help file for its command to understand the full range of specific options available. These typically include key elements like marker shapes and sizes; coloration of lines, markers, and fill elements; transparency and added text; and so on. All of these elements will allow you to create the exact visual components you want to display and there are a large number of resources on using graphical elements to efficiently convey information to readers. Therefore we do not cover these elements in this section.

However, some elements are common to all graphs and it is typically beneficial to standardize these components across all the graphs you create for a single piece of work. One workable setting that covers the main bases is the following code, which creates global macros called easily into all graphs. The specific settings here are not recommendations, but are for illustration purposes of common graphical elements. In particular, this code:

• Left-aligns the graph title
• Sets the background colors to white
• Turns off axis lines
• Rotates y-labels 90 degrees
• Left-aligns the x-axis title
• Removes coloration and bordering from the legend

These settings are implemented as follows:

// For -twoway- graphs
global graph_opts ///
  title(, justification(left) color(black) span pos(11)) ///
  graphregion(color(white)) ///
  xscale(noline) xtit(,placement(left) justification(left)) ///
  yscale(noline) ylab(,angle(0) nogrid) ///
  legend(region(lc(none) fc(none)))

// For -graph- graphs
global graph_opts_1 ///
  title(, justification(left) color(black) span pos(11)) ///
  graphregion(color(white)) ///
  yscale(noline) ylab(,angle(0) nogrid) ///
  legend(region(lc(none) fc(none)))

Two further primary settings will be desired when creating graphs for publication purposes: the file type of the exported image file and the aspect ratio (width-to-height) of the file. The aspect ratio is set using the ysize() or xsize() options, with integers as the arguments.

The choice of file type is also important. PNG images tend to be of reasonable quality and natively viewable on all operating systems as well as on web browsers when stored in places like GitHub and Zenodo. However, PNG images will typically be insufficient quality for print media; journals may prefer "lossless" TIFF or EPS images. These may not be natively viewable in your operating system. You should never use graph save to create .gph files unless you intend to combine graphs later. (Similarly, the saving() option is discouraged in all other uses.)

One way to implement these settings is with code like the following. Note the file type is explicit in the file path extension for the graph export command:

sysuse auto.dta , clear

scatter price mpg ///
  , nodraw ${graph_opts}
  
  graph draw , ysize(7)
  graph export "scatter.png"

Graphical schemes

Graphical schemes apply a large number of these options simultaneously, and in doing so they provide one of the highest degrees of cross-system consistency that is possible in creating graphs. Stata includes several built-in graphical schemes; the familiar "Stata blue" graphs are created using the s2color scheme.

The graph scheme can be changed using the set scheme command. Stata will use the sysdir path to search for matching graph schemes, so for example a third-party scheme file (like Uncluttered) might be included in the top-level directory of a repository and applied in the run file by writing:

sysdir set PERSONAL "${directory}/"
set scheme uncluttered

This directs Stata to search for scheme-uncluttered.scheme and apply it to all graphics created while Stata remains open. This is a simple scheme which incorporates many of the universally-applicable options above for all graphs, particularly region coloring and axis marking. As with any third-party scheme, you should read the documentation; notably, this scheme provides a specific color palette and turns off the legend by default.

One thing that schemes cannot do, apparently, is control the default graphics font. This can be done using graph set, as in graph set window fontface "Helvetica".

Combining Stata graphics

Combining multiple graphs into a single image is an excellent way to present various elects of a single analysis at the same time. Combining graphs is especially useful when facing constraints on the number of allowable exhibits, or when one or more graphical elements are very simple but important.

There are two main approaches to combing graphs: overlaying multiple pieces of information on the same set of axes, or combining multiple visualizations into a single image with multiple panels (either aligned or not, although Stata handles alignment somewhat poorly).

Overlaying graphics is accomplished using twoway syntax. In twoway, the graph axes are abstract, so with some abuse of notation it is possible to draw just about anything. Starting from the first axis, and proceeding in order of the commands written, Stata will layer graphs on top of each other on the same set of axes. Including a second (possibly invisible) axis allows further possibilities. For example, with the Uncluttered scheme applied and Helvetica set as the graph font, we might write the following twoway command:

  twoway ///
  /// Stacked histogram using total/subset approach
    (histogram date ///
      , freq yaxis(2) fc(gs14) ls(none) start(19997) width(7) barwidth(6) ) ///
    (histogram date if voucher_use == 0 ///
      , freq yaxis(2) fc(gs10) ls(none) start(19997) width(7) barwidth(6) ) ///
  /// Positivity
    (lpoly mtb date if voucher_use == 0 , lc(black) lw(thick) lp(solid)) ///
    (lpoly mtb date if voucher_use == 1 , lc(red) lw(thick) lp(solid)) ///
    (lpoly rifres date if voucher_use == 0 , lc(black) lw(thick) lp(dash)) ///
    (lpoly rifres date if voucher_use == 1 , lc(red) lw(thick) lp(dash)) ///
  /// Data collection
    (function 0.8 , lc(black) range(20193 20321)) /// 
      (scatteri 0.8 20193 "Round 1" ,  mlabcolor(black) m(none) mlabpos(1)) /// 
    (function 0.8 , lc(black) range(20814 20877)) /// 
      (scatteri 0.8 20814 "Round 2" ,  mlabcolor(black) m(none) mlabpos(1)) /// 
  /// Overall options 
  , legend(on size(vsmall) pos(12) ///
      order( ///
        2 "TB Tests Done, non-PPIA" ///
        1 "TB Tests Done, PPIA" ///
        3 "TB Positive Rate, non-PPIA" ///
        4 "TB Positive Rate, PPIA" ///
        5 "Rifampicin Resistance, non-PPIA" ///
        6 "Rifampicin Resistance, PPIA" )) ///
    ${hist_opts} xoverhang ///
    ylab(${pct}) ytit("Weekly Tests (Histogram)", axis(2)) ///
    xtit(" ") xlab(,labsize(small) format(%tdMon_CCYY))

If we did, we would obtain something like:

Alternatively, we might like to display information in panels that would not layer well together, or from commands which cannot be combined by twoway. For example, after creating some graphs with user-written commands (and including their panel titles), we might write:

  graph combine ///
    "${git}/outputs/f-discontinuity-1.gph" ///
    "${git}/outputs/f-discontinuity-2.gph" ///
    "${git}/outputs/f-discontinuity-3.gph" ///
    "${git}/outputs/f-discontinuity-4.gph" ///
    , altshrink

And we would obtain something like:

The graph combine command provides many options for customizing the layout and alignment of the graphs included. The user-written grc1leg command may also be useful when all of the visualizations included in the final image are intended to share a common legend. To save processing time when combining graphs, consider rendering the underlying graphs using the nodraw option, which saves graph rendering until the combined graph is drawn. Rendering the Graph window is computationally costly in Stata and is best avoided whenever possible.

Specific Visualization Approaches

The graph command

The graph command creates visualizations of one or more variables in the dataset. The graph command creates visualizations which have a Y-axis and a categorical axis.

For example, we might write:

graph hbar ///
  (mean) price (median) price (max) length ///
, asc yvaroptions( label(labsize(vsmall)) ///
    relabel(1 "Mean of Price" 2 "Median of Price" 3 "Max of Length") ) ///
  over(foreign) by(rep78 , c(1))  ///
  ysize(7) blabel(bar,size(vsmall))

And we would obtain:

The graph command also provides a range of syntaxes for other graphing functions, such as drawing, saving, and exporting graphs. These are not described here and - other than these - most should rarely be used.